+ ~ -
 
Article icon.

A Monument of French Folly

Read me now! Export to PDF, including full article record, author information, and annotation.
Author Charles Dickens
Genres Cross-genre i
Prose: Essay i
Prose: Leading Article i
Prose: Report i
Subjects Agriculture; Fishing; Forestry; Gardening; Horticulture
France—Commerce
Great Britain—Commerce
National Characteristics; Nationalism
Details
Index
Other Details
Printed : 8/3/1851
Journal : Household Words
Volume : Volume II
Magazine : No. 50
Office Book Notes
Memowell-mannered cattlemarket and abattoir
Columns10.25
Payment-
Views : 2728

Dickens here continues his vigorous support of the public pressure on the City of London's governing body, the Court of Common Council, to accept the 1849 Royal Commission on Smithfield's recommendation that the market be relocated in a less central and densely populated part of London. The Council's extreme reluctance to adopt this course was hardly surprising given that the City was, according to A. Forshaw and T. Bergström (Smithfield Past and Present, 2nd edn, [1990], p. 57) raking in a net profit of almost £10,000 a year from tolls imposed on Smithfield traders (one old penny per head per beast and one shilling per score of sheep – W. Thornbury, Old and New London [6 vols, 1879–85], Vol. 2 [n. d.], p. 350).


      This 'reeking central abomination', as a correspondent of The Times called it (31 January 1851, p. 6, col. 4), had been the subject of attack for many years, one of the most memorable depictions of its horrors being Dickens's own in Oliver Twist (Ch. 21). Dickens had also collaborated with Wills on an early HW article, 'The Heart of Mid-London' (Vol. I, 4 May 1850), containing harrowing descriptions of the suffering inflicted on the animals at Smithfield (see Stone, Vol. I, pp. 101–11); and published (Vol.1, 29 June 1850) an even more horrifying account, 'The Cattle-road to Ruin' by R. H. Horne, describing how livestock was got to Smithfield and the appalling conditions obtaining in London slaughterhouses. Horne also contributed some verses on the subject, 'The Smithfield Bull to his Cousin of Nineveh', to the 15 March issue of HW [Vol. II]. In 'Lively Turtle' [HW, Vol. II, 26 October 1850] Dickens had mocked a fatuous pro-Smithfield speech by Councilman Henry Taylor and he recalls it in the first paragraph of this piece.
      The distinguished scientist Sir Richard Owen was a member of the Royal Commission (in his speech Taylor had raised a laugh by objecting to this on the grounds that Owen 'had some crotchets in his head about sanitary reform) and a vigorous proponent of the idea of moving the livestock market to a healthier site. Parliament eventually passed the Smithfield Market Removal Bill in 1852 and the last market was held on the old site in 1855, the new one being located in Copenhagen Fields, north of Islington.
     For this article Dickens made a special trip (10–15 February) to Paris to inspect the Poissy market and the city abattoirs ('they will make a decent description, I think,' he wrote to Wills [Pilgrim, Vol. VI, p. 290]. Napoleon had issued regulations concerning the long-established livestock market at Poissy and ordered the construction of five clean new slaughterhouses in Paris 'outside the populated areas to replace the old abattoirs in the heart of the city which were real hives of infection' (M. Guerrini, Napoleon and Paris [1970], p. 177). These slaughterhouses, one of which was at Montmartre, were all put into use in 1818.
     The reference to James Bruce concerns his Travels to Discover the Source of the Nile in the Years 1768, 1769 [etc] (5 vols, Edinburgh, 1790). In Abyssinia Bruce found that the corpses of criminals slain for treason, murder, and violence, on the high-way at certain times, were seldom buried: 'the streets of Gondar are strewed with piece of their carcases, which bring the wild beasts in multitudes into the city as soon as it becomes dark....The dogs used to bring pieces of human bodies into the house and court-yard, to eat them in greater security' (Vol. III, p. 288).
      The Times, which campaigned relentlessly against the continuance of Smithfield Market, reprinted Dickens's description of Poissy under the heading of 'The Smithfield of Paris' (6 March 1851, p. 4, col. 5).
      There are two characteristically Dickensian language-games in this piece: the rendering of idiomatic French into the literal rather than the idiomatic English equivalent ('brave infants' instead of 'lads', etc.); and the periphrastic avoidance of swear words (p. 335: 'Damn your eyes!' was a common nineteenth-century oath).

Literary allusions

  • 'all who run...may read': John Keble's Christian Year [1827], 'There is a book, who runs may read';
  • 'the roast beef of England': Fielding's Grub Street Opera [1731], Act 3, Sc. 3;
  • 'prunes are ill for a green wound': Shakespeare, Henry IV Part Two, Act 2, Sc. 1 (the correct reading is 'prawns');
  • 'Britons never, never': James Thomson's 'Rule, Britannia', Alfred, Act 2, scene the last (1740);
  • 'potent, grave and common counselling Signors': adapted from Shakespeare, Othello, Act 1, Sc. 3.

Author: Michael Slater; © J. M. Dent/Orion Publishing Group, Dickens' Journalism Volume II: 'The Amusements of the People' and Other Papers: Reports, Essays and Reviews, 1834-51 (1996). DJO gratefully acknowledges permission to reproduce this material.

Click here for further information about texts cited.

Attachments (0)

Who's Online

We have 416 guests and 2 robots online.

Profile Information

Application afterLoad: 0.000 seconds, 0.28 MB
Application afterInitialise: 0.016 seconds, 1.00 MB
Application afterRoute: 0.020 seconds, 2.05 MB
Application afterDispatch: 0.380 seconds, 3.64 MB
Application afterRender: 0.436 seconds, 3.91 MB

Memory Usage

4131328

32 queries logged

  1. SELECT *
      FROM jos_session
      WHERE session_id = 'c4ac36859a5255ff4ced5a6dd6c5f75a'
  2. DELETE
      FROM jos_session
      WHERE ( TIME < '1638414193' )
  3. SELECT *
      FROM jos_session
      WHERE session_id = 'c4ac36859a5255ff4ced5a6dd6c5f75a'
  4. INSERT INTO `jos_session` ( `session_id`,`time`,`username`,`gid`,`guest`,`client_id` )
      VALUES ( 'c4ac36859a5255ff4ced5a6dd6c5f75a','1638415993','','0','1','0' )
  5. SELECT *
      FROM jos_components
      WHERE parent = 0
  6. SELECT folder AS TYPE, element AS name, params
      FROM jos_plugins
      WHERE published >= 1
      AND access <= 0
      ORDER BY ordering
  7. SELECT id
      FROM jos_toc_blocks
      WHERE alias = 'a-monument-of-french-folly'
  8. SELECT id
      FROM jos_toc_blocks
      WHERE alias = 'a-monument-of-french-folly'
  9. SELECT *
      FROM jos_toc_blocks
      WHERE id = '526'
  10. UPDATE jos_toc_blocks
      SET hits = ( hits + 1 )
      WHERE id='526'
  11. SELECT template
      FROM jos_templates_menu
      WHERE client_id = 0
      AND (menuid = 0 OR menuid = 70)
      ORDER BY menuid DESC
      LIMIT 0, 1
  12. SELECT id
      FROM jos_toc_blocks
      WHERE alias = 'a-monument-of-french-folly'
  13. SELECT id
      FROM jos_toc_blocks
      WHERE alias = 'a-monument-of-french-folly'
  14. SELECT *
      FROM jos_toc_blocks
      WHERE id = '526'
  15. CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE IF NOT EXISTS tmp_table_blocks_subjects_links (PRIMARY KEY pkey (id_estate)) SELECT id_estate, COUNT(*) AS cnt
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_subjects_links  
      GROUP BY id_estate;
  16. CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE IF NOT EXISTS tmp_table_blocks_genres_links (PRIMARY KEY pkey (id_estate)) SELECT id_estate, COUNT(*) AS cnt
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_genres_links  
      GROUP BY id_estate;
  17. CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE IF NOT EXISTS tmp_table_blocks_documents (PRIMARY KEY pkey (id)) SELECT block_id AS id, COUNT(block_id) AS cnt
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_documents
      GROUP BY block_id;
  18. CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE IF NOT EXISTS tmp_table_blocks_links (PRIMARY KEY pkey (id)) SELECT block_id AS id, COUNT(block_id) AS cnt
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_links
      GROUP BY block_id;
  19. CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE IF NOT EXISTS tmp_table_blocks_authors (PRIMARY KEY pkey (id)) SELECT id_block AS id, COUNT(id_block) AS cnt
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_authors  
      GROUP BY id_block;
  20. SELECT block.*,        IFNULL(periodical.title, "NA") AS title_periodical,        IFNULL(volume.title, "NA") AS title_volume,        IFNULL(magazine.title, "NA") AS title_magazine,        documents.cnt AS document_count,        links.cnt AS link_count,        subject.cnt AS subject_count,        genre.cnt AS genre_count,        authors.cnt AS author_count
      FROM jos_toc_blocks AS block  
      LEFT JOIN jos_toc_magazines AS magazine
      ON block.id_magazine = magazine.id
      LEFT JOIN jos_toc_volumes AS volume
      ON block.id_volume = volume.id
      LEFT JOIN jos_toc_periodicals AS periodical
      ON block.id_periodical = periodical.id
      LEFT JOIN tmp_table_blocks_subjects_links AS subject
      ON block.id = subject.id_estate
      LEFT JOIN tmp_table_blocks_genres_links AS genre
      ON block.id = genre.id_estate
      LEFT JOIN tmp_table_blocks_documents AS documents
      ON block.id = documents.id
      LEFT JOIN tmp_table_blocks_links AS links
      ON block.id = links.id
      LEFT JOIN tmp_table_blocks_authors AS authors
      ON block.id = authors.id
      WHERE (block.published = 1)
      AND (block.id = 526)
      ORDER BY id_magazine, id_page, ordering ASC  
      LIMIT 20
  21. SELECT *
      FROM jos_toc_magazines
      WHERE id = '56'
  22. SELECT *
      FROM jos_toc_periodicals
      WHERE id = '1'
  23. SELECT *
      FROM jos_toc_volumes
      WHERE id = '4'
  24. SELECT document.* , IF(fixto_table.block_id = 526, TRUE, FALSE) AS fixto  
      FROM jos_toc_documents AS document  
      LEFT JOIN  ( SELECT *
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_documents    
      WHERE block_id = 526 ) AS fixto_table
      ON document.id = fixto_table.document_id  
      WHERE (document.published = 1)
      AND (fixto_table.block_id = 526)
  25. SELECT document.* , IF(fixto_table.block_id = 526, TRUE, FALSE) AS fixto  
      FROM jos_toc_documents AS document  
      LEFT JOIN  ( SELECT *
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_documents    
      WHERE block_id = 526 ) AS fixto_table
      ON document.id = fixto_table.document_id
      WHERE (document.published = 1)
      AND (fixto_table.block_id = 526)
      ORDER BY title ASC  
      LIMIT 20
  26. SELECT link.* , IF(fixto_table.block_id = 526, TRUE, FALSE) AS fixto  
      FROM jos_toc_links AS link  
      LEFT JOIN  ( SELECT *
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_links    
      WHERE block_id = 526 ) AS fixto_table
      ON link.id = fixto_table.link_id  
      WHERE (link.published = 1)
      AND (fixto_table.block_id = 526)
  27. SELECT link.* , IF(fixto_table.block_id = 526, TRUE, FALSE) AS fixto  
      FROM jos_toc_links AS link  
      LEFT JOIN  ( SELECT *
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_links    
      WHERE block_id = 526 ) AS fixto_table
      ON link.id = fixto_table.link_id
      WHERE (link.published = 1)
      AND (fixto_table.block_id = 526)
      ORDER BY title ASC  
      LIMIT 20
  28. SELECT r.id, r.title, r.alias, r.names, r.surname
      FROM jos_toc_authors AS r  RIGHT JOIN jos_toc_blocks_authors AS l
      ON  r.id = l.id_author  
      WHERE l.id_block = 526
      ORDER BY r.surname ASC
  29. SELECT insignia.id, insignia.title, IFNULL(link.stamp, 0) AS stamp , insignia.definition
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_genres AS insignia  
      LEFT JOIN ( SELECT id_insignia, COUNT(id_insignia) AS stamp
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_genres_links
      WHERE id_estate = 526
      GROUP BY id_insignia) AS link
      ON insignia.id = link.id_insignia
      ORDER BY insignia.title ASC
  30. SELECT insignia.id, insignia.title, IFNULL(link.stamp, 0) AS stamp  
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_subjects AS insignia  
      LEFT JOIN ( SELECT id_insignia, COUNT(id_insignia) AS stamp
      FROM jos_toc_blocks_subjects_links
      WHERE id_estate = 526
      GROUP BY id_insignia) AS link
      ON insignia.id = link.id_insignia
      ORDER BY insignia.title ASC
  31. SELECT id, title, module, POSITION, content, showtitle, control, params
      FROM jos_modules AS m
      LEFT JOIN jos_modules_menu AS mm
      ON mm.moduleid = m.id
      WHERE m.published = 1
      AND m.access <= 0
      AND m.client_id = 0
      AND ( mm.menuid = 70 OR mm.menuid = 0 )
      ORDER BY POSITION, ordering
  32. SELECT guest, usertype, client_id, DATA
      FROM jos_session
      WHERE client_id = 0

Language Files Loaded

Untranslated Strings Diagnostic

None

Untranslated Strings Designer

None